Skip to main content

Adversarial Respect: Seeing the Humanity in Challenging Situations



There’s a quiet lesson in leadership that often goes unspoken: the people we negotiate with, even in moments of tension, are not enemies—they are professionals, doing their jobs with conviction, purpose, and care.

Over the past few months, I’ve been deep in contract negotiations with our teachers union. There were times when discussions felt heavy, progress was slow, and the stakes were high. At moments, it felt like we were on opposite sides of an impassable divide.

And yet, someone recently shared a term with me that reframed the entire experience: adversarial respect. The idea that you can deeply respect someone even while you disagree—because you recognize that they, too, are standing up for what they believe is right. That phrase stuck with me. It was exactly what I had felt but hadn’t yet named.

Our negotiations were not without strain. But they were honest. And they were human. There was movement, give-and-take, and a shared commitment to find a path forward—not just for ourselves, but for the students and families we serve. In that tension, there was also trust, even if unspoken. A belief that, in the end, we were all trying to do the right thing, just from different vantage points.

In the final agreement, I see fairness. I also see fiscal challenges. Meeting the salary goals we established will require some tough choices—perhaps even reducing some staffing in the future to preserve core programs. But I’m willing to make those tradeoffs because they reflect a deeper value: respect for the educators who show up every day for our children.

This process reaffirmed a foundational truth about authentic leadership: you don’t have to win every point to lead with integrity. You just have to stay grounded in who you are, remain open to others’ perspectives, and never lose sight of the shared mission.

Leadership is not about avoiding conflict. It’s about navigating it with empathy. And sometimes, the most transformative growth happens not in agreement, but in dignified disagreement.

The Authentic Pause

Reflect. Reconnect. Realign.

  • Think of a time when you stood on opposite sides of an issue with someone. How did you maintain respect?

  • How can you practice “adversarial respect” in your current leadership challenges?

What assumptions can you release in order to see an opponent as a committed professional?


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Exploring Possibilities: The Grass Isn’t Greener, Just Different

  This past winter, I found myself in the thick of a quiet job search. Not because I was actively seeking to leave my role as superintendent, but because I was curious. I wanted to dip my toes into the waters of possibility and see what was out there. Admittedly, I was frustrated. Leading is hard. And when the pressure mounts and the days get heavy, it’s easy to wonder: Is there something better out there? For anyone who has ever entertained the thought of a new opportunity, whether quietly scrolling job listings or submitting an application in earnest, you’ll know the pull. The question isn’t just, “Can I do something else?” It’s often, “Would something else be easier? Would it make me happier?” During this process, I found some intriguing opportunities. Positions with more money. Jobs with less visibility. Roles with potentially fewer headaches. But as I moved through interview processes and deeper into reflection, one truth became clear: those jobs weren’t better. They were simp...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Power of "We" In Uncertain Times

                                                            NYC night out after a long day of workshops--we were being goofy! It is easy to think of governance and leadership as separate lanes—one for policy and one for practice. But when those lanes merge, when a board and superintendent operate as a true governance team, something remarkable happens. Decisions become grounded in purpose, not politics. Now more than ever, collaboration matters. With uncertainties surrounding federal funding, uncertainty from the U.S. Department of Education, and the growing complexity of ensuring equitable access for every student, our shared responsibility has never been clearer. The last few days I was in New York City alongside my entire Board of Education, including our student ex officio member, Alani, attending the New ...
Post a Comment
Read more